| |
| META TOPICPARENT | name="FirstEssay" |
|---|
| |
<
< | It is strongly recommended that you include your outline in the body of your essay by using the outline as section titles. The headings below are there to remind you how section and subsection titles are formatted. | | | The Stereotypical Foreigner
-- By MerryLi - 17 Feb 2016 | |
>
> | As Trump continued to dominate Republican polls, his wall building proposal has gone from being outrageously incredulous to being deceptively effective. The fuel for this "madness" is the deep fear for immigrants, as they "take over" jobs, settle in large numbers, supposedly commit crimes, and insert their foreign language and culture into what is perceived to be what pure America should be like. | | | In America | |
<
< | Subsection A | >
> | A word that may come to mind in the English context when talking about foreignness and foreigners seems to be xenophobia - a sense of fear towards the foreign and subsequently the strange. It is a much different sentiment from treating something/someone as exotic, which has romantic connotations under the foreignness. Frequently, whether something/someone is perceived to be exotic or invokes xenophobia is decided by merely how distant the foreign thing is. When what is foreign is also distant, there seems to be more curiosity than fear. The Anglo-Saxon culture is adventurous, and the people explore the unknown, finding it to be full of opportunities. When what is foreign suddenly demands the attention at home, by war or by settlement, the exotic became fearsome. | | | | |
>
> | This psychological change seems to be rooted in a sense of superiority. Historically, there was technological superiority that enabled one side to explore or exploit while the other side got explored or exploited. The imbalance of physical power easily turned into a sense of societal and moral superiority - one group’s physical advantages must mean that its intangibles are superior because they produced better results. This reasoning has been used quite often, in Germany, in Japan, and of course in America. Americans subscribe to the idea of America being the greatest country in the world because of the military advantage, the commercial domination, the scientific and technological wonder, and people attribute these achievements to the superiority of the system - democracy, liberty, Christianity or its values, the Constitution and more are all part of the American system that people believe to be the greatest in the world. | | | | |
<
< | Subsub 1
Subsection B
Subsub 1
Subsub 2 | >
> | It is not certain at all that this reasoning is correct, or even that the qualities people believe the system to possess are more than mere form and propaganda. Yet empirical observations suggest that it is both a fear of losing these qualities and a fear of providing the benefits of these qualities to those who used to be inferior that drives the fear of foreignness. But probably to the horror of some, America’s desirability continuously attracts foreigners to become immigrants, and immigrants to claim Americanness. And an irony lies between inclusiveness as an American value and the desire to keep America “pure.” | | | | |
>
> | In China | | | | |
>
> | In contrast to the American dichotomy, foreignness is perceived quite differently in China. There are still two different attitudes, loosely one positive and one negative, though there is more nuance. The positive word towards foreignness may be 崇洋媚外 (chong yang mei wai), which translates to “worshiping the west and fawning the foreign,” or similar to xenophilia, as the modern coinage goes. This modern word emerged as a China in decline encountered the West, and found it to be more advanced than itself. Unfamiliar with inferiority, people swarmed to praise the desirable foreign, hoping to free ride on whatever amazing inventions the foreign could bring so that they would not fall behind. But ironically it was also because people were unfamiliar with inferiority, harsh criticism against those who are too intimate with the foreign quickly took hold. The word 崇洋媚外 may denote a positive impression of the foreign, but it is intertwined with a feeling of despise towards those who are willing to believe that the superiority of the foreign is unattainable. For better or worse, the word’s legacy goes beyond the time when the country was entrenched in war and poverty. It is very much still a prevalent sentiment today, which reflects the Chinese psyche that agonizes over the distance between the great China in imagination and the flawed China in reality. | | | | |
<
< | In China | >
> | The negative attitude towards foreigners belittles them, using words such as “小” (little/small) and “蛮夷” (savage foreigner). This attitude has a much longer history, which goes back probably all the way to the beginning of the civilization when the civilized people encountered the surrounding tribes. The usage of these words is still quite common today, with some changes in definition, and is used to describe not only the inferior but also the hostile. But what is not obvious in the words themselves is that there is very little, if any, fear behind them. Apathy, and occasionally pity, are what the Chinese feel towards those that are inferior and hostile. | | | | |
<
< | Subsection A | >
> | So the difference | | | | |
<
< | Subsection B | >
> | It cannot go unnoticed that the discrepancy between the English romanticized foreign and the Chinese one – the former is the unknown, the faraway, the simple and pure, while the latter is the known, the influential, the advanced and sophisticated. And the difference between the English disliked foreign and the Chinese one is that the former is imminent and threatening, while the latter is distant and harmlessly ignorant. Yet the similarity that may escape the attention of many is that neither culture wishes to change. For America, the foreign may be a temporary escape, but with that escape, the foreign is improved by the sheer presence of the superior; for China, the foreign may have characteristics that deserve recognition and imitation, but with the appropriation of those characteristics, the foreign remains the same while China progresses for the better. | | | | |
>
> | The stereotypical foreigner in the eyes of some Americans is one whose own culture and society is inferior, in one way or another, and either finds America desirable and wishes to be a part of it, or is jealous of America and wishes to “bring it down.” The stereotypical foreigner in the eyes of many Chinese is one who either represents all things better or all things worse, neither of whom impacts what China itself does. | | |
You are entitled to restrict access to your paper if you want to. But we all derive immense benefit from reading one another's work, and I hope you won't feel the need unless the subject matter is personal and its disclosure would be harmful or undesirable. |
|