Law in Contemporary Society

View   r5  >  r4  ...
TheWireHamsterdam 5 - 02 May 2008 - Main.JaredBaumgart
Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="WebPreferences"
So I know everyone is busy with finals but I wanted to see people's reaction to this. This past term I got into the HBO series "The Wire" and ended up watching the whole show throughout the course of the term. However, one of the most interesting and intriguing ideas in the show was Bunny Colvin's creation of "Hamsterdam" in the third season. "Hamsterdam" is literally a three or so block safe zone created in the middle of a completely abandoned part of West Baltimore where the street dealers are allowed to sell their drugs with no fear of arrest, so long as they also promise to avoid the use of violence. The idea is that by centralizing the street level drug trade into these tiny enclaves the rest of the district will be drastically improved, pointless arrests (that are contributing to the over crowding of our police system) will be reduced, and violent crimes will also hopefully decrease. The problem of course is that the free zones themselves are then likely to become absolute hell-holes, not to mention all the potential problems if word gets out that you can go buy heroin, cocaine, and other highly addictive and dangerous drugs with absolutely no fear of arrest. On the other hand, by centralizing the drug trade and accordingly the addicts into these few free zones relief organizations (meals on wheels, needle exchanges, health services for testing, etc) can also have a far bigger impact while spending less money and expending fewer resources trying to find the people they are trying to help. These are obviously just a summary of the arguments both for and against this idea, and even though it seems pretty much untenable in real life I thought it was very interesting when I saw it on the show. Moreover, "The Wire" is actually written by former Baltimore cops and one gets the impression when watching the show that they think this idea might be one of the only real ways to actually deal with the drug/violent crime problem in America's inner cities. Therefore, given all our discussions this term about the problem with America's criminal justice system, the over-crowding of prisons, etc I thought I'd toss this idea out there to see what people thought of it. I know everyone's busy studying for finals but I'm interested to hear your responses and see whether people actually think this idea is good, realistic, or perhaps just the jumping off point for a different, perhaps less drastic, plan.
Line: 24 to 24
 I remember watching that episode and it is one of the few that I have seen. I think its a very effective idea, particularly when the drug trade involves so much gang violence, as it does in Baltimore. In a city that struggles so dramatically to have economic development, it is certainly a way of addressing the problems of widespread drug dealing. Morally, there may be a different question, and there are racial aspects to the allowance of a drug dealing area in the middle of a predominantly minority inhabited area, but it is interesting as an idea nonetheless. Thanks for sharing.

-- AndrewWolstan - 02 May 2008

Added:
>
>

Oz had a similar concept in Season 4. Adebisi (led the black gang) was allowed to do whatever he want (drugs, booze, rape) as long as there was no violence. The concept worked for awhile and there was no violence, but eventually Adebisi couldn't keep control over all the prisoners, and violence crept back in. So while the system started as a tradeoff between drugs and violence, it ended with both drugs and violence. I don't know how closely this relates to the Wire but it seems to raise 2 potential issues

1) We may not be able to rely on drug dealers to obey the rules

2) The system may be designed more to improve appearances and less to improve actual inner-city life. (In Oz, Adebisi was allowed to sell drugs because the prison director wanted to establish a record of no violence in the cellblock he presided over. We wouldn't want Baltimore to create Hamsterdam just so that the mayor or the police chief can say they've reduced violence, while quality of life is worse than before.)

-- JaredBaumgart - 02 May 2008

 
 
<--/commentPlugin-->
\ No newline at end of file

Revision 5r5 - 02 May 2008 - 17:30:09 - JaredBaumgart
Revision 4r4 - 02 May 2008 - 06:05:10 - AndrewWolstan
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform.
All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
All material marked as authored by Eben Moglen is available under the license terms CC-BY-SA version 4.
Syndicate this site RSSATOM