ZDNet:  Reviews | Downloads | Tech Update | Prices
Page OneApplicationsNetworkingeBusinessHardwareCommentary



Applications


Microsoft: Palladium not just for Windows
By Matt Loney
ZDNet (UK)
July 8, 2002, 5:05 AM PT


TalkBack!


Following widespread skepticism of Microsoft's motives for developing its trusted computing platform, the software giant this week moved to reassure the software community that Palladium will not be limited to Microsoft's platforms.

Although Microsoft has said it will publish the source code for Palladium, free software and open-source advocates are concerned that license terms will prevent non-proprietary software from using the application programming interfaces.

Speaking to ZDNet UK, Microsoft Palladium group product manager Mario Juarez said it is still too soon to say what license will be used for Palladium interfaces, but indicated that it would not necessarily be as restrictive as past examples. "We do realize that we are an important company and that we have a responsibility to the industry. The goal is for as many people as possible to be able to take advantage of what we are talking about here. We are not trying to drive this as a Microsoft-only initiative."

Juarez was responding to criticisms that the Palladium initiative is in part designed to lock out other platforms--in particular Linux and other open-source and free software operating systems. Juarez admitted that Microsoft's track record of making its platform hooks--or application programming interfaces--available to third parties had created a suspicion in the open-source community.

In late March, Microsoft published a document that outlined how third-party developers can use Common Internet File Sharing (CIFS), a protocol developed by Microsoft that specifies how Windows PCs share files with servers. Although publishing the document should have made it easier to write software that incorporates CIFS, it contained a crucial restriction that prohibits using information in the document to build software governed by the General Public License (GPL).

Some believe that any licence connected to Palladium will follow a similar route. "People are right to be suspicious," said Juarez. But, he said, "it puts us in a difficult position having to say we don't have all the answers yet because that invites speculation and suspicion, but to say we have all the answers would bring other concerns."

Juarez did add a caveat. "We are talking about Microsoft intellectual property and we will take steps to make sure this is not plundered," he added. The main consideration for Microsoft, said Juarez, will be integrity (of the Palladium software), and while it may be possible to achieve this through a consortium, Microsoft will not pursue such a path if it feels that integrity is being compromised. "The technology we build has to be truly good technology that has integrity. That is where we will make our stand. We will not sacrifice integrity of the Palladium platform," he said.

The acknowledgement that development of a trusted platform such as Palladium must be handled carefully comes just a few years after Intel fumbled the introduction of the unique processor ID into its chips. Juarez said that such considerations are the reason that Microsoft is revealing rough plans for Palladium before the details are worked out--although some in the industry believe that Microsoft only hurriedly rushed out what it had on the technology after learning that Newsweek said it was planning to break an embargo.

"We do have white papers and other materials in the queue," said Juarez. "We are in the phase of articulating a vision; one of the things we know goes wrong is that we go a long way down the road and then people ask why did we make those decisions. Equally, there is a risk we incur by going out early, but hopefully we can get people to challenge us and make us think in new ways."

Juarez said that it to build dialogue that Microsoft started releasing information on Palladium so early in the process. "We only have one choice and that is to do it right. If we don't it won't work. That's why we're going out early."

Related Quotes
Quotes delayed 20+ minutes

  MICROSOFT CORP MSFT 52.24 -0.97

Quote Lookup  Symbol Lookup  Streaming Real Time Quotes
E-mail this story! Printer Friendly

Also on ZDNet
Maximize Windows XP with this guide from TechRepublic.
Solve your computer problems with live tech help at ZDNet.
Beware the Deskstar: Check out IBM's new 120GB hard drive.
Compare specs on our editors' top five favorite cell phones.
Find a new job today in ZDNet's Career Center.


 TalkBack: Post your comment here
       Re: Microsoft: Palladium not just for Windows  Internet User

       Why does Microsoft set ZDnets news agenda?  Nigel Johnstone

       Re: Microsoft: Palladium not just for Windows  C Welsh

       ....not just for Windows  Joe Cuervo

       Microsoft has no place in security  Doctor Weezil

       Simple, 95% of users are MS users  Don Rupert

       Re: Simple, 95% of users are MS users  Rich K

       Re: Simple, 95% of users are MS users  Chris Maxwell

       Re: Simple, 95% of users are MS users  Phil Pennington

       Palladium is pure evil  David Skoll

       Re: Palladium is pure evil. Oh PULLEEESE!  Don Rupert

       Re: Palladium is pure evil. Oh PULLEEESE!  David Skoll

       I care about OWNERSHIP rights...  Don Rupert

       Re: I care about OWNERSHIP rights...  Sean K

       Re: I care about OWNERSHIP rights...  Chris Maxwell

       Re: Palladium is pure evil. Oh PULLEEESE!  Kevin Sullivan

       When did RIAA decide computers should play CD  Don Rupert

       Re: When did RIAA decide computers should play CD  Phil Pennington

       Re: When did RIAA decide computers should play CD  Douglas Husemann

       Re: When did RIAA decide computers should play CD  Eddie Chandler

       Re: When did RIAA decide computers should play CD  Chris Maxwell

       Re: Palladium is pure evil. Oh PULLEEESE!  Frederick Wissing

       Re: Palladium is pure evil. Oh PULLEEESE!  Chris Maxwell

       Re: Palladium is pure evil  Stewart Cannon

       Re: Palladium is pure evil  Chris Maxwell

       Re: Palladium is pure evil  Wade Prater

       Re: Palladium is pure evil  Patrick Mitchell

       Re: Microsoft: Palladium not just for Windows  Rich K

       Here's a clue folks...  Don Rupert

       Re: Here's a clue folks...  Rich K

       Re: Here's a clue folks... Follow along  Don Rupert

       Re: Here's a clue folks... Follow along  Phil Pennington

       Re: Here's a clue folks... Follow along  James Jones

       Re: A Clue for Don  Patrick Mitchell

       Clipper chip redux  Arvid Erickson

       Re: Here's a clue folks...  Phil Pennington

       You assume...  Don Rupert

       Re: You assume...  Phil Pennington

       Re: Here's a clue folks...  Sean Mitchell

       (NT) Don, the magic word is? "BUY" "BUY" "BUY" "BUY"  thomas drazul

       Re: Here's a clue folks...  John Johnson

       Palladium - even the concept sucks!  Eddie Chandler

       Palladium - A time for outrage  George Mitchell

       Re: Microsoft: Palladium not just for Windows  David Skoll

       Re: Microsoft: Palladium not just for Windows  Walter Dnes

       Re: Microsoft: Palladium not just for Windows  David Skoll

       Re: Microsoft: Palladium not just for Windows  David Skoll

       Re: Microsoft: Palladium not just for Windows  David Skoll

       Palladium, not for anyone  Frederick Wissing

       Re: Palladium is pure evil  David Skoll

More Replies


 Search


 
 Tech Update

Face to face with Red Hat's Matthew Szulik

Sun's a software giant, too!

Managing Microsoft licensing

More apps analysis...

 News in Brief

Yahoo reports profit  04:29PM

Army Web site recruits 400,000 gamers  04:05PM

Pressplay CEO steps down  03:33PM

Verizon calls up electronic city guide  02:22PM

nCube upgrades video-on-demand software  11:44AM

More...

 Commentary

SOMOGYI SOMOGYI
Apple: Taking OS X security seriously--finally More...

COURSEY COURSEY
Why we can't trust Microsoft's 'trustworthy' OS More...

More Commentary...


ZDNet Tech Update
Featured Resource Centers

 News Tools

 News Archives

 News in Brief

 News for your PDA

 Contact Us

 Corrections
Newsletters
ZDNet News E-mail Alert
Security Update
OS Update




All newsletters
FAQ
Manage my newsletters


ZDNet
Services: IT Jobs | Top 5 Phones | Windows XP Guide | Portal Pitfalls | Find PDAs | SAP vs. Siebel

      CNET Networks: Builder | CNET | GameSpot | mySimon | TechRepublic | ZDNet
About CNET Networks 

About Us | Feedback | Your Privacy | Service Terms | Advertise | ZDNet Jobs
 
Copyright © 2002 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved. ZDNet is a registered service mark of CNET Networks, Inc. ZDNet Logo is service mark of CNET Networks, Inc.