ZDNet:  Reviews | Downloads | Tech Update | Prices
Page OneApplicationsNetworkingeBusinessHardwareCommentary



eBusiness


Copyright law open for comment
By John Borland
Special to ZDNet News
October 14, 2002, 5:27 AM PT


TalkBack!


Federal copyright regulators are opening the door for new exceptions to a controversial copyright law that has landed one publisher in court and a Russian programmer in jail.

The United States Copyright Office is launching a rare round of public comment on rules that bar people from breaking through digital copy-protection technology on works such as music, movies, software or electronic books. Regulators aren't looking to change the law, but they are looking for public suggestions on what kinds of activity should be legalized in spite of the rules.

This is only the second time in the controversial law's five-year history that the public has been able to pitch in with suggestions for exceptions. Critics of the law say they will use the opportunity to draw wider public attention to the way its restrictions can affect ordinary people.

Click Here!

"Outside the copyright community, most people don't know this exists," said Fred von Lohmann, a staff attorney with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a digital civil liberties group. "We're already planning to submit comments and organize comments by others. We're hoping that by the time the December deadline rolls around, a lot more people will be aware of this."

The portion of copyright law coming under the public microscope is the so-called anti-circumvention clause of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which bars people from circumventing "technological measure that effectively controls access to a work," as well as creating or distributing tools to do the same.

That law has been used by Hollywood in attempts to keep the DeCSS software program, which can be used in the process of copying DVDs, off the Web. It was the trigger for the FBI's arrest of Dmitry Sklyarov, a Russian programmer who had helped create technology that could crack Adobe Systems' e-book protections.

Free-speech advocates have challenged the constitutionality of the law, and the last round of public comments on the anti-circumvention clause three years ago drew an avalanche of comments from critics.

However, the copyright office says it has only a very limited scope to define exceptions to the law. In the last round, it carved out just two activities that could be exempted from the law. People could break through encryption on lists of Web sites blocked by Web filtering programs and could break protection on software or other "literary works" in cases where the copy control was obsolete or interfering with the functioning of the program, the office said.

This time around, the office is again asking for specific examples of cases where the law's restrictions cause "actual instances of verifiable problems occurring in the marketplace." Inconvenience or "theoretical critiques" are not enough, the office warned.

Von Lohmann cited several examples of types of activity that might merit exemption, including the "clean flicks" practice in which people delete scenes deemed objectionable from Hollywood movies and rent these movies to parents or other concerned viewers.

Public comments are due to the Copyright Office by Dec. 18.


E-mail this story! Printer Friendly

Also on ZDNet
Find the tech gear you need in CNET's Back to School guide.
Get ahead of the competition with the BizTech Library.
Improve your PC's performance with the Memory Configurator.
Don't miss up-to-the-minute IT commentary on TechRepublic's blog.
Laid off? Find a new IT job today in our Career Center.


 TalkBack: Post your comment here
       Re: Copyright law open for comment  Internet User

       Ain't gonna happen.  Jane Dirt

       View the customers as the asset not content  def leppard

       Re: Ain't gonna happen.  Internet User

       the hard part  Richard Balzak

       Fortune says content co.'s tuning out consumer  def leppard

       Re: Copyright law open for comment  Don Jackson

       Proof  Robert Rosenthal

       Alienate entire customer base to protect content ?  def leppard

       Re: Copyright law open for comment  Art Guy

       www.musicunited.org  def leppard

       Re: www.musicunited.org  Internet User

       Re: www.musicunited.org  Art Guy

       Re: www.musicunited.org  Marc Johnson

       Copyright law open for comment  William Coxe

       What a bunch of cry babies!  Bit Byte

       I'll be retrieving my music 1 way from here on in  def leppard

       Scrap it completely  Nigel Johnstone

       Re: Scrap it completely. They did....  Bit Byte



 Search


 
 Tech Update

Future of Microsoft business solutions

Is Linux taking over the enterprise?

Spam: Out of control

More e-business analysis...

 News in Brief

Internet Society takes over '.Org' domain  10:15AM

Creative player picks fight with iPod  09:29AM

Siebel sued over employee options  08:31AM

Color screens seen as a boon for Nokia  07:45AM

Deep Fritz beats the human--still trails chess match  07:08AM

More...

 Commentary

FARBER FARBER
ZDNet's Editor-in-Chief takes the pulse of the enterprise More...

MELLO MELLO
Find out how tech fits into your business plans More...

More Commentary...


ZDNet Tech Update
Featured Resource Centers
Sybase:
Request for more info, Whitepapers and more.
Gateway:
Hardware, Products and more.

 News Tools

 News Archives

 News in Brief

 News for your PDA

 Contact Us

 Corrections
Newsletters
Tech Update Today
Security Update
OS Update




All newsletters
FAQ
Manage my newsletters


ZDNet
Services: IT Jobs | New WebFerret | Premium Research | Web Hosting | Windows XP Guide

      CNET Networks: Builder | CNET | GameSpot | mySimon | TechRepublic | ZDNet
About CNET Networks 

About Us | Support | Your Privacy | Service Terms | Advertise | ZDNet Jobs 
 
Copyright © 2002 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved. ZDNet is a registered service mark of CNET Networks, Inc. ZDNet Logo is service mark of CNET Networks, Inc.