0  

LOOK FOR 
 Get Wired News Your Way
  Newsletters, handheld versions, alerts ...
 



Privacy Matters
Today's Headlines
11:00 a.m. June 7, 2002 PDT

Cursor Company's Conduct Cursed

Craig Gets Listed in Replay Suit

ReplayTV Users Sue Hollywood

Act Would OK Snail Mail Searches

Airport Face Scanner Failed

Survey: Opt-Out Is a Cop-Out

White House Cool to Hollings' Act

A Bad Year for Privacy

Carnivore's New Leash on Life?

Web Group OKs Privacy Standards

Court Overturns Bookstore Ruling

Nothing to Yahoo Over New E-Rules

More ...
 Craig Gets Listed in Replay Suit
By Joanna Glasner



Print this  •  E-mail it


2:00 a.m. June 7, 2002 PDT
Craig Newmark is probably one of the last people in need of greater name recognition.

As founder of the San Francisco-based community website Craigslist, Newmark already has his name pop up in more browser windows per day than most people could conceivably type.

See also:
•  ReplayTV Users Sue Hollywood
•  They Know What You're Watching
•  TiVo Town or Sonicblue City?
•  ReplayTV on Sale Despite Suits
•  Lights, Camera, Hollywood Tech
•  Picture Yourself in Politics
•  Keep an eye on Privacy Matters

However, as lead plaintiff in a lawsuit filed on behalf of users of digital recording devices, Newmark is finding his name listed in a new venue.

Shortly after the suit was filed in a Los Angeles federal court Thursday, it picked up a nickname: Craig vs. Hollywood.

Newmark, who said he joined the suit out of concern for privacy rights rather than desire for publicity, said he was "flattered, amused and embarrassed" by the new name (along with jokes on geek discussion site Slashdot.org over who should play him in the film version of the suit).

Beyond the banter, the suit struck a chord with many users of digital recording devices, such as TiVo and ReplayTV, seeking to protect their ability to skip over commercials and to keep data about viewing habits private.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) assisted in preparing the suit, which was filed on behalf of five Replay TV users. It charges that 27 studios, including Disney, Time Warner and NBC, wrongfully claimed that personal use of the devices constitutes copyright infringement.

The plaintiffs are seeking a court judgment declaring that their use of the devices to record programs and skip over commercials is entirely legal.

So far, the suit hasn't gone over well with Hollywood. On Thursday, the studios named in the action issued a statement through the Motion Picture Association of America that called the suit "nothing more than a publicity stunt." The studios are currently suing Sonicblue, maker of ReplayTV, charging that its devices enable users to steal copyrighted programming.

Newmark said he first considered joining the EFF-led suit after participating on a panel discussion on nonprofits and technology with Shari Steele, the organization's executive director.

Steele mentioned that the EFF was planning to take legal action against film studios seeking to prevent use of digital recording devices like Replay TV. As an avid user of Replay's devices for the past couple of years, Newmark said he would be interested in joining the effort.

The four other plaintiffs named in the suit are Keith Ogden, a broker in the San Francisco area; Glenn Fleishman, a Washington journalist; Phil Wright, a video editor in California; and Shawn Hughes, an electrical contractor in Georgia.

Newmark said he was particularly perturbed by the studio's success several weeks ago in obtaining a court order requiring Sonicblue to turn over detailed viewing data of its users. Sonicblue is seeking to overturn the order.

"I was fairly angry that the Hollywood studios had gotten a court order to force Replay to spy on people," Newmark said. "I thought that this isn't a joke. This literally is a case."


Have a comment on this article? Send it.
Printing? Use this version.
E-mail this to a friend.


Related Wired Links:

ReplayTV Won't Quit, Won't Quit
June 4, 2002

Sonicblue Freed From Monitoring
June 3, 2002

Kazaa's File-Sharing Swap
May 20, 2002

Napster Now Bertelsmann's Baby
May 17, 2002

Making Copy Right for All
May 17, 2002

'Dork' Duo Finally Get Noticed
May 16, 2002

They Know What You're Watching
May 3, 2002

Can the World Be Copyrighted?
Feb. 26, 2002

Webby Winners Have Their Say
July 19, 2001





     » Lycos Worldwide © Copyright 2002, Lycos, Inc. All Rights Reserved.  Lycos® is a registered trademark of Carnegie Mellon University.
     About Terra Lycos | Help | Feedback | Jobs | Advertise | Business Development

     Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of the Lycos Network Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions